|
Game 1: Tuesday, Aug. 25 @ 9:00pm
Lincoln Tavern 4 - Fat Baby 2
Every once in awhile a game comes along that's a "must watch" - tonight game one of this series was a must watch due to the fact that we had two of the very best pitchers squaring off in a playoff game. Jimmy Pinkston and Nick French were on the mound which meant there would be plenty of strikeouts and runs would be tough to come by. But who would prevail? Let's get to the scoresheets and break it down.
Lincoln Tavern drew first blood in the top of the first when lefty Conor Gleason launched one deep into the night, 1-0. If there was a fence in right field, then this ball would have cleared it by 40 feet. Aside from that one big hit, French and Pinkston were doing their thing and shutting down the attack. Gleason's solo home run would be the only run scored until the top of the fourth.
Lincoln's offense manufactured a pair of runs on Drew Blake's RBI single to right field, 3-0. That lead seemed huge as French was being very stingy - allowing just four hits at this point of the game. The tall lefty threw another two innings of shutout ball and we headed to the bottom of the sixth inning with Lincoln still ahead 3-0.
In the bottom of the sixth, Lincoln's defense committed multiple errors which led to an unearned run, 3-1. Brendan Busa then singled home another run and suddenly Fat Baby had life, 3-2. With runners on first and second, Cam O'Brien stepped into the batter's box. The powerful righty fouled off pitches and worked the count to full. French then threw and off speed breaking ball that was called a third strike. O'Brien disagreed but the ump said it caught the inside corner. French himself admitted it was a 50/50 ball - sometimes you get that call and sometimes you don't.
We moved to the top of the seventh with Lincoln clinging to a one run lead. Taylor Ferguson looked to help matters when he doubled to left center. Two batter's later, Ryan O'Rourke drove him home with a single to right, making it 4-2. It was a huge run considering that Fat Baby had the lower half of the lineup due up in the bottom of the seventh.
French quickly retired the first two batters on groundball outs. Andrew Stover drew a walk which gave Fat Baby some hope but it was brief. Two pitches later, French produced the third out and the game one victory went to French and the Lincoln Tavern.
 |
 |
 |
| Nick French | Conor Gleason | Jimmy Pinkston |
Game 2: Thursday, Aug. 27 @ 9:00pm
Fat Baby 5 - Lincoln Tavern 3
Behind a steady pitching performance from Jimmy Pinkston and a timely offensive attack that kept finding answers, Fat Baby walked away with a victory in game two, leveling the best of five series at one game apiece.
Fat Baby's lineup immediately put the ball in play against Jose Bonilla, who started for Lincoln Tavern. After surrendering two hits in the first inning but not allowing a run, Bonilla was tagged for a run in the top of the second when Greg Bosse doubled and later scored the game's first run, 1-0 Fat Baby. They added another run in the third on a pair of singles coupled with an infield error, 2-0 Fat Baby.
Lincoln got on the scoreboard in the bottom of the third when Dave Corcoran (3 hits, 2 RBI) doubled and scored on Conor Gleason's single, 2-1. In the bottom half of the inning, Brian Dunphy and Andrew Stover hit one out singles. Kyle Cheever followed with a sacrifice fly to right and Fat Baby built a 3-1 lead. Neil Corcoran followed with an RBI single which brought home Stover, making it 4-1 Fat Baby.
Pinkston retired the side in the home half of the fourth and Fat Baby was in control and looking to pad their lead. They did just that in the fifth when Sammy McDonald (3 hits) led off with a double and scored on Jordan Gorham's single, 5-1 Fat Baby.
Pinkston and Fat Baby were greeted with three straight Lincoln singles to start the bottom of the fifth inning. If Lincoln was going to get back into this game, then this was their moment. The very underated Dave Corcoran came through with another clutch hit (his 3rd) and drove home a pair of runs in the process, 5-3. Pinkston beared down and retired the next batter on a productive groundout to first base as both baserunners moved up into scoring position. With the third and fourth hitters due up, Lincoln had to feel good about their chances. However, Pinkston got a pop out to third base and then a fly out to center field - opportunity wasted.
Now with Lincoln back in the game, Nick French took over the pitching duties and threw two straight scoreless innings. However, he was matched batter-for-batter by Pinkston as he did not allow a baserunner after the fifth inning, retiring nine in a row to nail down the game two victory. Game three should be a beauty!
 |
 |
 |
| Jimmy Pinkston | Sam McDonald | Dave Corcoran |
Game 3: Wednesday, Sep. 2 @ 6:00pm
Lincoln Tavern 3 - Fat Baby 8
After splitting the first two games, Fat Baby jumped on Lincoln Tavern early, got two-three-run homers, and rode a brilliant pitching performance from Jimmy Pinkston to victory here in game three. The win puts Fat Baby in the driver's seat while also putting Lincoln just a loss away from elimination.
Pinkston was the difference-maker on the mound. The big righty worked six scoreless innings, surrendered just five hits and struck out five, repeatedly shutting down Lincoln whenever the visitors threatened. The only batter to give him trouble tonight was Drew Blake who doubled and smashed a two-run home run.
Brendan Busa got the scoring started in the bottom of the first when he blasted a three-run homerun onto East First Street, 3-0 Fat Baby. Lincoln didn't have an answer nor a run through the first three innings - Pinkston by this point had four strikeouts, including three in a row!
In the bottom of the third, it was more trouble for Lincoln by way of the long ball. After a leadoff walk followed by a Sam McDonald single, seldom seen Cam O'Brien launched a three-run dinger that put Fat Baby in front 6-0. They would add two more runs on a Mark Preziosi single and were now comfortably ahead, 8-0.
As expected, the veteran Lincoln squad didn't go quietly. A leadoff walk followed by a double by Conor Gleason put runners in scoring position for Taylor Ferguson. The free swinging slugger tried to get Lincoln back into it with one swing but came up a little short. However, Ferguson's fly ball was deep enough to score a run and Lincoln was finally on the scoreboard. Drew Blake then stepped in and sent another softball flying over the fence in left-center, 8-3. Suddenly Lincoln was on the attack and right back into the game.
However, it was short lived as Pinkston and the Fat Baby defense played flawless softball after Blake's home run. Through the final three-plus frames, Pinkston only allowed two hits and no runs. Fat Baby wins this one and will look for a series clinching win in game four.
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Jimmy Pinkston | Brendan Busa | Cam O'Brien | Drew Blake |
Game 4: Tuesday, Sep. 8 @ 9:00pm
Fat Baby 6 - Lincoln Tavern 14
After winning games two and three, Fat Baby had the series momentum on their side. However, a rainout on Thursday and then the long Labor Day weekend gave the series pause and when the games resumed, the Fat Baby squad didn't return with the same fire and/or personel and paid the price here in game four.
Fat Baby were missing two key players (Neil Corcoran and Brian Dunphy) and were forced to go with a different looking batting order. Lincoln's pitcher, Nick French, had no trouble retiring the side in order and we moved to the bottom of the first.
In the bottom of the first, Taylor Ferguson (3 hits, 2 HR) hit his first of two homeruns on the night which gave Lincoln a 1-0 lead. Fat Baby quickly answered when Cam O'Brien led off the top of the second with a solo blast to left, 1-1.
The Lincoln attack were back on the offense in the bottom of the inning when Justin Lynch (3 hits) singled home a run to put Lincoln back on top, 2-1. Fat Baby would then commit an infield error and another run would cross the plate, 3-1.
French retired the side in order in the top of the third and we moved to the home half of the inning where the game and perhaps the series got away from Fat Baby.
Dave Corcoran reached base on another infield miscue - again, Fat Baby is missing two starters and have players filling in and playing different positions. Pitcher Jimmy Pinkston retires the next two batters and should have been out of the inning. Instead, Fat Baby commits another error which extends the inning (5 outs). Ryan O'Rourke (4 hits, 4 runs) then singles home Corcoran to make it 4-1. Kevin Powers (2 hits, 5 RBI) follows with a crushing three-run blow onto East First Street and just like that it's 7-1. Lincoln would score two more runs (six unearned runs) in the inning and carry a 9-1 lead into the fourth.
The two clubs would evenly swap runs back and forth for the next three innings with each side scoring five runs. In the end, Lincoln takes advantage of some mistakes and ties the series. Josh Rivera (3 hits, 2 RBI) was the lone star for Fat Baby in this one.
Something to watch for in game five is the fact that pitcher Jimmy Pinkston didn't record a strikeout in this game. Previously, he had pitched eighteen straight games where he had at least three or more strikeouts. Fat Baby doesn't stand a chance in this series if he isn't in top form. That's the risk you take when you hitch your wagon to one arm.
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Ryan O'Rourke | Nick French | Kevin Powers | Josh Rivera |
Game 5: Wednesday, Sep. 9 8pm
Lincoln Tavern 25 - Fat Baby 2
Sometimes in sports, the game is over before the two teams step foot on the playing surface - and that's what we had here tonight. When you play all through the spring and summer months and the succes or failure of your season comes down to one game, every player on your roster should be fired up and ready to play. Instead, we had a team reach out to the league with several different excuses about why they couldn't play the game as scheduled. Then they play a lifeless game and get absolutely rocked - I have some ideas as to how this happens and will share my thoughts as we break this lopsided game down.
Lincoln Tavern strikes first when they manufacture a run on a pair of hits and a sacrafice fly by Drew Blake, 1-0. Not much harm done but Fat Baby knows they're going against pitcher Nick French and can't afford to fall too far behind.
Fat Baby puts a runner on base in the home half of the inning but can't advance him. Everything changes in the top of the second when the squeaking wheels fall off this jalopy.
With nobody out, Lincoln loads the bases on a walk, single, and an infield error. Brett Belcastro singles home a run and Tim Zeng follows with an RBI single, 3-0. Dave Corcoran is then walked to force home another run, 4-0. At this point, it's clearly not the pitcher's night but Fat Baby doesn't have any answers or anyone to turn the ball over to. The brass never gave thought to the possibility of your starting pitcher not having his best stuff in a key elimination game. Instead, they rolled their guy out there for 96 of a 104 total innings this season. It was "all in" and this is where it finally caught up to them and they paid the price.
The onslaught in the top of the second was far from over - it was like a car wreck on the expressway - you didn't want to look. Another infield miscue led to another run - then a walk, a hit batter, a two-run single by Ryan O'Rourke and by the end of it, Lincoln put up ten runs and were leading 11-0 in a series deciding game. That shouldn't happen to any team. In a game of this magnitude, you need to have options.
The game limped along to the third inning where the skies opened up (rain) and we didn't see any runs scored on either side.
In the top of the fourth, Kevin Powers connected for another home run to left making it 12-0. Fat Baby's offense finally responds with a pair of runs in the bottom of the fourth, 12-2. Ho-hum.
The damn finally broke in the top of the fifth and the Fat Baby starter had enough. E4, single, E6 and that was the end of the night for their star pitcher - I don't blame him! Greg Bosse takes over on the mound and had a tough task in front of him with the heart of the Lincoln order due up. Something tells me the Lincoln hitters had read some of the social media comments as they didn't let up the attack. Walk, single, walk, single, a two-run double by Frankie Reyes and seven more runs were across the plate making it, 19-2. Lincoln wasn't done yet. Single, single, walk, single, home run leads to six more runs and a total demolishing of the Fat Baby softball team.
What happened? Injuries, attrition, personalities, and leadership - our playoff season is long and can take the toll on any team. Fat Baby didn't have the roster depth so when a key player went down or was missing in action, they didn't have the next man up to fill the void. They may have had the names on the roster but didn't have the commitment from those players. Secondly, the handling of the pitching - expecting one guy to throw every inning of your season is asking way too much. What happens if he gets hurt in the first game of the playoffs? Fat Baby left themselves open and Lincoln exploited the weakness. Lastly, Fat Baby argued about the schedule, argued about pitching, argued about playoff elgibility, told us how terrible the umpires are, and argued about an honest clerical mistake by a scorekeeper. Creating turmoil during the season will take its toll on a team - some players may enjoy it but others don't want any part of that kind of behavior. Playing in a league is supposed to be fun but the fun was lost along the way.
Lincoln Tavern will now move on to play the two-time defending champions, Clock Tavern Sluggers in a best of five series final for the M Street Cup.
 |
 |
 |
| Drew Blake | Nick French | Frankie Reyes |
Lincoln Tavern wins series 3-2
|